Dennett on free will
As I mentioned previously, I went to a talk this evening by Daniel Dennett, Is science showing that we don’t have free will, wherein he argued that determinism is not incompatible with the concept of free will, and is in fact irrelevant. He puts forward the (on the surface convincing) case that determinism, being a function of physics, is independent of free will, which is a function of evolution.
I won’t even attempt to analyse his arguments here, as I only made very sporadic notes through the hour and a half presentation, although in general I thought that he made quite a good case, but I will refer back to the recording when it becomes available.
This was the first time that I’ve seen Dennett in person (he’s much taller than I imagined) having previously only ever heard audio recordings and seen brief video interviews. As I’d hoped, he was thoroughly engaging, humorous, straightforward and a joy to listen to.
The only thing that someone who didn’t have any exposure to philosophy in general, or Dennett in particular, was his single use of the term “skyhook”, although the context would have given the listener an idea of to what he was referring.
My choice of quote of the evening (paraphrased as I didn’t have a pen and paper to hand at that precise moment):
There’s a technical term for that period of time between a decision and regret: the onosecond.
I’ll post a link to the podcast (it was also video recorded, so it may even be a video podcast) as and when it’s made available on the University of Edinburgh podcast page.
For Tales, here’s the video showing the motor proteins in action (as on the front cover of Nature 27 June 2003) (1m15s in).
And two books to buy: I Am a Strange Loop by Douglas Hofstadter and The Omnivore’s Dilemma by Michael Pollan. As if I don’t already have enough to read…
And finally, congratulations to Professor Dennett on his honourary DLit (and to Michael Palin too!) from the University of Edinburgh.
Eight things meme
SQA responds
Hoots mon, there’s a Xenoo loose, aboot this hoose!
The Scotsman: Fatwa on female circumcision
Christians on “The Secret”
BBC: With this ring I thee indict
Keith Allen will burn in hell (AKA Keith Allen vs the Phelps)
The christian thought process?
The Hitchenses on BBC Question Time
UK Government says “no” to creationism/ID in science classes
Happy World Humanist Day
Go greenies!
Dawkins to appear at the Edinburgh International Book Festival
Humanist Symposium reminder
-
Twitter
-
Chat
Join nullifidian on IRC in #atheism at blitzed.org or use the chat right here
Or head on over to Secular Chat.
-
Feeds
-
Current readers
-
Recently played
-
Recent Comments
-
Recent Posts
-
Tags
- activism
- advertising
- anti-atheism
- anti-science
- Arkell v. Pressdram
- atheism
- atheist bus
- bad arguments/logical fallacies
- BBC
- BBC News
- bible
- bigotry
- blasphemy
- blog
- books
- British Humanist Association
- cartoon
- catholicism
- Charles Darwin
- chart
- christianity
- Christian Voice
- creationism/intelligent design
- culture
- demotivation
- dogma
- Edinburgh
- education
- employment
- entertainment
- evidence
- evolution
- evolution denial
- FAIL!
- faith/belief
- free speech
- fundamentalism
- government and politics
- government and politics
- homophobia
- homosexuality
- humanism
- humour
- hypocrisy
- I demand respect!
- image
- islam
- Jerry Springer:The Opera
- legal
- letters
- literalism
- LOL
- lying for Jesus
- media
- medicine and healthcare
- medicine and healthcare
- Mohammed
- news
- nullifidian.net
- opinion
- persecution complex
- personal
- petition
- photo
- Photoshop
- prayer
- quote
- Ray "Tampon Case/Banana Man" Comfort
- reality
- religion
- response
- Richard Dawkins
- Sam Harris
- scepticism
- science
- Scotland
- scripture
- secularism
- special treatment/religious privilege
- special treatment/religious privilege
- Stephen "Birdshit" Green
- superstition
- taking the piss
- technology
- television
- the arts
- The Guardian
- The Independent
- theocracy/anti-secularism
- theocracy/anti-secularism
- The Stupid It Burns
- The Telegraph
- The Times
- thought
- UK
- USA
- video
- web
- WhiskyTangoFoxtrot
- woo woo
-
Archives
- April 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- June 2006
