The Independent: Johann Hari on oppressive religions
In yesterday’s The Independent Johann Hari had an excellent article describing why he doesn’t respect oppressive religious ideas, or indeed any religious ideas that can’t be backed up by that little thing people like me like to call “reality”.
The meat of the article:
All people deserve respect1, but not all ideas do. I don’t respect the idea that a man was born of a virgin, walked on water and rose from the dead. I don’t respect the idea that we should follow a “Prophet” who at the age of 53 had sex with a nine-year old girl, and ordered the murder of whole villages of Jews because they wouldn’t follow him.
I don’t respect the idea that the West Bank was handed to Jews by God and the Palestinians should be bombed or bullied into surrendering it. I don’t respect the idea that we may have lived before as goats, and could live again as woodlice. This is not because of “prejudice” or “ignorance”, but because there is no evidence for these claims. They belong to the childhood of our species, and will in time look as preposterous as believing in Zeus or Thor or Baal.
When you demand “respect”, you are demanding we lie to you. I have too much real respect for you as a human being to engage in that charade.
But why are religious sensitivities so much more likely to provoke demands for censorship than, say, political sensitivities? The answer lies in the nature of faith. If my views are challenged I can, in the end, check them against reality. If you deregulate markets, will they collapse? If you increase carbon dioxide emissions, does the climate become destabilised? If my views are wrong, I can correct them; if they are right, I am soothed.
But it’s worth reading the whole thing.
- I disagree with this, some people are not worthy of respect as people but only as humans [↩]
Possibly related posts:
- HuffPo: Johann Hari on oppressive religions (redux) ...
- Coverage of religions in The Independent ...
- Letters/The Independent: Dodging the issue ...
- The Independent: Ask Dawkins ...
- The Independent: Another christian who just doesn’t “get it” ...
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Tags: bigotry, I demand respect!, news, opinion, reality, religion, special treatment/religious privilege, The Independent
Comments
This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.
10933 Responseshttp://www.nullifidian.net/2009/01/29/the-independent-johann-hari-on-oppressive-religions/The+Independent%3A+Johann+Hari+on+oppressive+religions2009-01-29+17%3A12%3A57nullifidian to “The Independent: Johann Hari on oppressive religions”
Blogroll (UK)
Blogroll
- Adult Christianity
- An Apostate’s Chapel
- Atheist Ethicist
- Atheist Hussy
- Atheist Media
- Atheist Perspective
- Atheist Revolution
- Bad Astronomy
- BEEP! BEEP! IT’S ME.
- Black Sun Journal
- Bligbi
- Canterbuty Atheists
- Chicken Girl
- Daylight Atheism
- Deep Thoughts
- Dwindling in Unbelief
- evanescent
- Evolution Space
- Evolved and Rat/i/onal
- Five Public Opinions
- Friendly Atheist
- Geoff Arnold
- Happy Jihad’s House of Pancakes
- Homosecular Gaytheist [and friends]
- Honjii’s Harangues
- Humanist Dad
- Irreligiosity
- Kazim’s Korner
- lol god
- LOLgod
- Lord J-Bar For Democracy, Not Theocracy
- No More Hornets
- One Good Move
- Oz Atheist’s Weblog
- Pharyngula
- Pooflingers Anonymous
- Possummomma (aka, Atheist in a mini van)
- Religion *is* a problem
- Saint Gasoline
- Sandwalk
- Sean the Blogonaut (new URL)
- See Mike Draw
- Sexy Secularist!
- Spanish Inquisitor
- Splendid Elles
- Stuff God Hates
- Stupid Dinosaur Lies
- The Atheist Experience
- The Atheist Jew
- The Barefoot Bum
- The Flying Trilobite
- The Iron Chariot
- The Perplexed Observer
- The Religion Virus
- The Uncredible Hallq
- toomanytribbles
- Unscrewing the Inscrutable
- Velocity Inversion
- Way of the Mind
- Wrong In Their Mind Tanks
Good Stuff
- Atheist Blogs Aggregated
- Center for Inquiry
- Centre for Inquiry
- Does God Exist?
- Encyclopedia of Life
- Fundies Say The Darndest Things!
- God Checker
- Humanist Society of Scotland
- Iron Chariots
- James Randi Educational Foundation
- Michael Shermer
- New England Skeptical Society
- Pat Condell’s Godless Comedy
- Planet Atheism
- Planet Humanism
- Robert M Price
- Sam Harris
- Science/AAAS
- Talk.Origins
- The Brights
- The Official God FAQ
- The RDF
- The Reason Project
- The Rejection of Pascal’s Wager
- The Science Network
Petitions
Petitions (closed)
- [failed] Abolish Faith Schools (UK)
- [failed] Ban Promotion of Faith in State Schools
- [failed] End Faith Schools
- [failed] Rename The ‘Church’ of Scientology under section 32 of the Companies Act
- [failed] Secularise the UK
- [failed] Tax Churches
- [ignored] Refuse state funding of church maintenance
- [partial success] Ban the usage of Narconon in any publicly funded orgianisation
- [partial success] Stop Islamic Sharia Law being used in Great Britain
- [partial success] Stop misleading advertising by religious groups
- [success] Recognise Atheists
- [success] Remove Creationist Literature from State Schools
-
Twitter
-
Chat
Join nullifidian on IRC in #atheism at blitzed.org or use the chat right here
Or head on over to Secular Chat.
-
Feeds
-
Current readers
-
Recently played
-
Recent Comments
-
Recent Posts
-
Tags
- activism
- advertising
- anti-atheism
- anti-science
- Arkell v. Pressdram
- atheism
- atheist bus
- bad arguments/logical fallacies
- BBC
- BBC News
- bible
- bigotry
- blasphemy
- blog
- books
- British Humanist Association
- cartoon
- catholicism
- Charles Darwin
- chart
- christianity
- Christian Voice
- creationism/intelligent design
- culture
- demotivation
- dogma
- Edinburgh
- education
- employment
- entertainment
- evidence
- evolution
- evolution denial
- FAIL!
- faith/belief
- free speech
- fundamentalism
- government and politics
- government and politics
- homophobia
- homosexuality
- humanism
- humour
- hypocrisy
- I demand respect!
- image
- islam
- Jerry Springer:The Opera
- legal
- letters
- literalism
- LOL
- lying for Jesus
- media
- medicine and healthcare
- medicine and healthcare
- Mohammed
- news
- nullifidian.net
- opinion
- persecution complex
- personal
- petition
- photo
- Photoshop
- prayer
- quote
- Ray "Tampon Case/Banana Man" Comfort
- reality
- religion
- response
- Richard Dawkins
- Sam Harris
- scepticism
- science
- Scotland
- scripture
- secularism
- special treatment/religious privilege
- special treatment/religious privilege
- Stephen "Birdshit" Green
- superstition
- taking the piss
- technology
- television
- the arts
- The Guardian
- The Independent
- theocracy/anti-secularism
- theocracy/anti-secularism
- The Stupid It Burns
- The Telegraph
- The Times
- thought
- UK
- USA
- video
- web
- WhiskyTangoFoxtrot
- woo woo
-
Archives
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- June 2006













I really try hard not to defaith people, but honestly, why won't some people just leave the rest of alone? Is it that hard?
Probably because they're convinced that their magic books tell them that they have to go out and make other people believe the contents of their magic books, annoying the shit out of the rest of us in the process.
What a great read! Thanks for the link.